The Old Courthouse Inn

This unique hotel, a converted courthouse, offers a distinctive and memorable stay, celebrated for its historic charm and antique decor that creates a museum-like atmosphere. Its signature feature is the immersive step back in time, appealing greatly to history enthusiasts and travelers seeking a truly unique experience rather than a generic hotel. Guests consistently highlight the comfortable beds, clean rooms, and the exceptional included breakfast. The hotel is an excellent fit for couples looking for a romantic and character-filled getaway, and its pet-friendly policy makes it suitable for those traveling with animal companions. To make the most of your stay, embrace the historical quirks of the building, such as potential hallway noise, and be sure to confirm breakfast timings if you have early morning plans.

Facilities & Amenities
Guests appreciate the blend of historical ambiance with modern conveniences. Rooms are equipped with mini fridges, Nespresso machines, and convenient charging ports by the beds, ensuring comfort and connectivity. While there isn't a traditional swimming pool, the hotel offers good Wi-Fi throughout. Shared amenities like microwaves, kettles, and irons are available in a common area, adding to guest convenience. The presence of air conditioning is also noted as a welcome modern touch. It's important to note that, due to the building's historic nature, there are stairs to access some areas, and some guests found the bathrooms to be on the smaller side.

Cleanliness & Room Comfort
The hotel consistently receives high praise for its cleanliness and the overall comfort of its accommodations. Guests frequently commend the comfortable beds and high-quality linens that ensure a restful night's sleep. Many rooms feature spacious layouts and modern amenities such as rain showers with excellent water pressure. While most rooms are described as quiet, some guests noted occasional hallway noise due to thin doors, a common characteristic of older buildings. A few reviews mentioned minor issues like a musty smell in one room or the sound of wind chimes outside, but these were generally considered minor inconveniences given the hotel's unique charm.

Dining & Food Quality
A standout feature of the hotel is the highly praised included breakfast, served at the attached Edie Rae's Cafe. Guests consistently describe the breakfast as delicious, amazing, and a significant value, often highlighting the cooked-to-order options from a comprehensive breakfast menu, including popular dishes like eggs benedict. The food quality is generally excellent, with many guests stating it was the best included breakfast they've experienced. However, a recurring point of feedback is the 9 am start time for breakfast, which can be late for guests with early travel plans, and the cafe's closure on Mondays. Some isolated comments mentioned issues with coffee taste or the quality of hash browns.

Location & Accessibility
The hotel boasts a central location within the historic Old Town, making it an ideal base for exploring the area. Guests appreciate its proximity to local attractions, with a brewery, various restaurants, and the historic Patricia Theatre all within easy walking distance. While the main part of town requires a short drive, the immediate surroundings offer a quiet and charming atmosphere. The hotel is also conveniently located a short drive from the ferry terminal. Parking is available and generally well-regarded, adding to the convenience for guests traveling by car.

Staff & Service
The staff at the hotel consistently receive glowing reviews for their friendly, helpful, and accommodating demeanor. Guests frequently highlight the personal service provided, with many appreciating the owner's welcoming approach and willingness to personally show guests to their rooms and explain amenities. The check-in process is described as quick and efficient, and the staff's attentiveness to guest needs, from providing extra linens to addressing minor issues, contributes significantly to a positive experience. The overall sentiment is that the staff go above and beyond to ensure a comfortable and enjoyable stay.

Additional Information
Beyond the standard amenities, the hotel offers several unique aspects that enhance the guest experience. Its pet-friendly policy is a significant draw for many travelers, allowing them to bring their furry companions along. The hotel's extensive antique decor and museum-like atmosphere are consistently mentioned as a key part of its charm, inviting guests to explore and discover historical artifacts throughout the building. Some guests even noted the presence of ghost stories or a "haunted hallway," adding to the unique character. For those departing before the 9 am breakfast service, the hotel thoughtfully provides early breakfast options like yogurt, muffins, and fruit in a common area.