35 Shore Road Shelter Island, Shelter Island, 11965, USA
Select dates to see prices and availability
See prices
Select dates to see prices and availability
See prices
Sunset Beach
Sunset Beach
Sunset Beach
Sunset Beach
Sunset Beach

Good to know

  • Mediterranean-Inspired Ambiance

    The location evokes a South of France feel, offering a transporting experience with its decor and beachside setting.

  • Sunset views from French bistro

    Savor French cuisine and cocktails on the terrace of the lively bistro/bar, offering picturesque sunset vistas.

  • Delicious Seafood Offerings

    Guests highlighted the amazing seafood, particularly the oysters and shrimp pasta, as standout menu items.

  • Shelter Island Country Club Proximity

    Golf enthusiasts will appreciate the hotel's location, a short 9-minute walk from the Shelter Island Country Club.

  • Direct Beach Access

    Located opposite Crescent Beach, enjoy easy access to the sand and surf for a relaxing seaside getaway.

  • Outdoor showers for beachgoers

    Rinse off after a day at the beach with convenient outdoor showers, ensuring a comfortable transition.

  • Flat-screen TVs with DVD players

    Enjoy in-room entertainment with flat-screen TVs and DVD players, perfect for relaxing after a day of exploring.

  • Exceptional Staff Hospitality

    Many reviewers praised the staff's friendliness, helpfulness, and attentiveness, enhancing the overall experience.

This summary was created by AI and might not be 100% accurate.

Rooms

  • Suite, 2 Double Beds, Private Bathroom, Bay View

    Suite, 2 Double Beds, Private Bathroom, Bay View

    • 1 2 Double Beds
    • Sleeps 2
    • A/C
  • Suite, 1 King Bed, Private Bathroom, Bay View

    Suite, 1 King Bed, Private Bathroom, Bay View

    • 1 1 King Bed
    • Sleeps 3
    • 480 sq ft
    • A/C

Similar stays

  • Popular choice
    Topping Rose House (Bridgehampton, USA)
    Hotel
    Topping Rose House
    8.7Excellent (939 ratings)
    Bridgehampton, 0.1 km to City center
    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices

Reviews

7.5
Good
based on 643 ratings from top 
sites
sites

Review summary

Summarized by AI from 70+ reviews · Last updated: 8 Sept 2025

The hotel is widely celebrated for its European-inspired ambiance, often likened to the French Riviera or St. Tropez, creating a unique and transporting experience right on Shelter Island. This distinctive atmosphere, combined with stunning sunset views and a vibrant people-watching scene, makes it a memorable destination. It is particularly well-suited for couples seeking a romantic getaway and young adults or socialites looking for a lively, trendy environment. Guests appreciate the blend of relaxation and a dynamic social scene, making it ideal for those who enjoy a chic, upscale vibe. To ensure a seamless experience, it is highly recommended to secure dining reservations in advance, especially during peak times, as the restaurant can become very busy. Additionally, guests should be prepared for a lively atmosphere, particularly in the evenings, which contributes to the hotel's unique charm.

Guest reviews

Excellent28%
Very good22%
Good16%
Fair12%
Poor22%

Top amenities

  • WiFi in lobby
  • WiFi in rooms
  • Parking
  • Pets
  • A/C
  • Restaurant
  • Hotel bar

All amenities

Property amenities

  1. Café
  2. Entrance hall/lobby
  3. Express check-in/check-out
  4. Parking
  5. Terrace
  6. Pet friendly
  7. Bar
  8. Non-smoking rooms
  9. Restaurant
  10. 24-hour reception
  11. Beach
  12. Sun umbrellas

For children

  1. Childcare

Wellness

  1. Massage

Accessibility

  1. Wheelchair accessible

Room amenities

  1. Openable windows
  2. Television
  3. Central heating
  4. Air conditioning
  5. Cosmetic mirror
  6. Minibar
  7. Desk
  8. Telephone
  9. Cable TV
  10. WiFi
  11. Free WiFi in rooms
  12. Flatscreen TV

Sports facilities

  1. Bike rental
  2. Hiking trail

Location

35 Shore Road Shelter Island, Shelter Island, 11965, USA

Distance from Sunset Beach

Transport

Shelter Island:4.8 km

Bradley International Airport:99.8 km

Greenport:2.9 km

Landmarks

Parrish Art Museum:18.8 km

Guild Hall:19.5 km

Water Mill Museum:18.3 km

Explore nearby attractions

Property info

35 Shore Road Shelter Island, Shelter Island, 11965, USA

Frequently Asked Questions about Sunset Beach

  • Is there a pool area at Sunset Beach?

    No, Sunset Beach doesn’t offer pool areas.

  • Are pets allowed at Sunset Beach?

    Yes, Sunset Beach has a pet policy that may vary based on the room type or availability. Please check with the hotel directly to learn about their pet policy.

  • Is parking available at Sunset Beach?

    Yes, Sunset Beach provides Parking for guests.

  • Where is Sunset Beach located?

    Sunset Beach is located at 35 Shore Road Shelter Island, 11965, Shelter Island, USA.

  • Which popular attractions are close to Sunset Beach?

    Sunset Beach Nearby attractions include Tweed New Haven Airport.

The prices and availability we receive from booking sites change constantly. This means you may not always find the exact same offer you saw on trivago when you land on the booking site.

Among Top Rated Hotels in Shelter Island

  • Popular choice
    Sound View Greenport (Southold, USA)
    Hotel
    Sound View Greenport
    7.9Good (2,756 ratings)
    Southold, 5.1 km to City center
    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • Popular choice
    The Menhaden (Southold, USA)
    Hotel
    The Menhaden
    9.5Excellent (835 ratings)
    Southold, 7.3 km to City center
    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • The Shoals Suites & Slips (Southold, USA)
    Hotel
    The Shoals Suites & Slips
    9.4Excellent (391 ratings)
    Southold, 2.9 km to City center
    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • Popular choice
    Faraway Sag Harbor (Sag Harbor, USA)
    Hotel
    Faraway Sag Harbor
    8.6Excellent (1,504 ratings)
    Sag Harbor, 0.9 km to City center
    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • Cliffside Resort Condominiums (Southold, USA)
    Hotel
    Cliffside Resort Condominiums
    8.7Excellent (946 ratings)
    Southold, 5.7 km to City center
    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • Popular choice
    Topping Rose House (Bridgehampton, USA)
    Hotel
    Topping Rose House
    8.7Excellent (939 ratings)
    Bridgehampton, 0.1 km to City center
    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • Vine & Sand (Southold, USA)
    Hotel
    Vine & Sand
    9.6Excellent (47 ratings)
    Southold, 1.4 km to City center
    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • Popular choice
    The Sagaponack (Bridgehampton, USA)
    Hotel
    The Sagaponack
    8.4Very good (409 ratings)
    Bridgehampton, 3.6 km to City center
    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • Popular choice
    Wainscott Woods Retreat (East Hampton, USA)
    Hotel
    Wainscott Woods Retreat
    7.2(9 ratings)
    East Hampton, 5.9 km to City center
    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices

Destinations near Sunset Beach