Narragansett Inn

The Narragansett Inn offers a unique step back in time, renowned for its historic charm and breathtaking views of the Salt Pond and New Harbor. This classic inn, welcoming guests since the late 1800s, retains much of its old-world character, making it an ideal choice for sightseers and history enthusiasts seeking an authentic Block Island experience. Its prime location near The Oar restaurant and various marinas also appeals to couples and groups of friends looking for convenient access to local attractions. Many returning visitors appreciate the consistent, laid-back atmosphere and the sense of community. For budget-conscious travelers who prioritize location and character over modern luxuries, this inn provides a compelling option. To enhance your stay, it is highly recommended to consider booking a room with a private bathroom, as this significantly improves the overall comfort, and to embrace the inn's rustic, vintage appeal rather than expecting contemporary hotel standards.

Facilities & Amenities
The inn maintains its historic character, which means it lacks some modern facilities and amenities. Most notably, there is no air conditioning throughout the property; guests rely on open windows and a provided fan for cooling, though some found the fan insufficient or broken. Many rooms lack screens on the windows, leading to issues with bugs entering, and windows often need to be propped open with wooden blocks, which some guests found concerning. Rooms typically do not include a TV, phone, or refrigerator. While some areas offer Wi-Fi, guests in the annex building frequently reported no Wi-Fi access. There were also recurring complaints about non-functional outlets in rooms, posing inconvenience and safety concerns. Despite these limitations, the inn offers comfortable outdoor seating areas and a relaxing porch with scenic views, which are highly appreciated by guests.

Cleanliness & Room Comfort
Guest experiences with cleanliness and room comfort are notably mixed. While some guests found their rooms to be clean and sufficient, many reported significant issues, particularly in the annex building, where rooms sometimes had an unpleasant damp smell and outdated carpets. Rooms are generally described as small, and while some found the beds comfortable, others did not. A major concern for many guests is the paper-thin walls, leading to considerable noise from neighboring rooms and hallways, impacting sleep quality. The availability of hot water is a frequent complaint, with some guests experiencing cold showers or no hot water at all, sometimes due to unannounced shut-offs. Shared bathrooms are consistently described as being in poor condition, often with visible mold, rotting wood, and a lack of tidiness. Even private bathrooms were sometimes criticized for their small size, mold issues, and non-existent water pressure. The absence of window screens often resulted in bugs and spiders entering rooms, further detracting from comfort.

Dining & Food Quality
The inn provides a basic breakfast offering, typically consisting of coffee and muffins, with some guests also noting the availability of random snacks throughout the day. While this complimentary offering is appreciated by some, others expressed disappointment, mentioning that the continental breakfast menu was sometimes incomplete or that the provided coffee was of poor quality. For a more substantial dining experience, guests frequently highlight the option to access a buffet at the nearby 1661 Inn, located about 1.5 miles away. This alternative dining option receives positive feedback, with many guests enjoying the variety and quality of food available there. The overall sentiment suggests that while the on-site breakfast is a convenient amenity, guests seeking a more robust or higher-quality meal may prefer to explore options outside the inn.

Location & Accessibility
The inn's location is consistently praised as one of its strongest assets, situated in the desirable New Harbor area. Guests appreciate its prime position, with the popular The Oar restaurant conveniently located in its backyard and within easy walking distance. The property offers breathtaking views of the Salt Pond, providing a serene and picturesque backdrop for guests. Its central location allows for easy walking access to the Old Harbor area and proximity to three marinas, making it highly convenient for exploring the island. Many guests find it an ideal base for getting around Block Island, especially for those using bicycles. Furthermore, a gorgeous beach is situated right across the lawn, offering direct access to coastal activities. This accessibility to key attractions and natural beauty significantly enhances the guest experience.

Staff & Service
The staff and service at the inn generally receive high praise from guests. Most guests describe the staff as exceptionally helpful, kind, and accommodating, contributing significantly to a positive stay. Many highlight the attentive service provided by the front desk team, who are often commended for their willingness to assist with various requests, including allowing guests to return and shower after checking out. The staff's commitment to ensuring a pleasant experience is evident, with some guests noting their flexibility with early check-in. There are also instances where staff went above and beyond, such as arranging a shuttle service to their sister property, the 1661 Inn, when booking errors occurred. While the overwhelming majority of feedback is positive, a few guests reported instances of less satisfactory customer service, particularly regarding responses to room condition complaints.

Additional Information
Guests should be aware that the inn, while historic, is often compared to a youth hostel experience by some, particularly concerning its rustic nature and shared facilities. Several reviews raise serious fire hazard concerns, citing issues like non-functional outlets and general disrepair in some areas. Additionally, guests reported significant security issues, noting that the main front door was frequently found propped open throughout their stay, which could be a concern for personal safety. These points highlight that while the inn offers a charming, old-world atmosphere, it may not meet contemporary safety or comfort standards for all travelers. It is important for prospective guests to manage their expectations regarding the property's condition and amenities, understanding that its appeal lies more in its historical character and location than in modern conveniences or rigorous upkeep.