Faraway Martha's Vineyard

This stylish and recently renovated property in Edgartown offers a memorable stay, particularly noted for its central location and beautiful pool and hot tub area. It caters well to a variety of guests, including couples seeking a romantic getaway, families looking for convenient access to local attractions, and individual travelers desiring a chic and comfortable base. The hotel's unique in-room amenities, such as record players, add a distinctive touch to the guest experience. To make the most of your visit, guests recommend taking advantage of the complimentary bikes to explore the island and being prepared for potentially challenging parking situations in the area.

Facilities & Amenities
Guests frequently praise the hotel's well-maintained pool and hot tub, which serve as a central hub for relaxation and enjoyment, even being heated for use in cooler months. The property also features a well-equipped fitness center, offering a convenient option for guests to stay active. Thoughtful touches like scattered seating areas and a cozy fire pit enhance the ambiance, providing inviting spaces for guests to unwind. While the hotel offers free Wi-Fi and bikes for exploring the island, it is important to note the absence of an elevator, which can be a consideration for guests with heavy luggage or mobility concerns. The hotel's signature scent, while appreciated by many for its relaxing quality, can be overpowering for some sensitive individuals.

Cleanliness & Room Comfort
The rooms are consistently described as clean, spacious, and beautifully decorated, reflecting a modern yet cozy aesthetic. Guests appreciate the comfortable beds and high-quality linens that contribute to a restful sleep. While many rooms offer pleasant views, some ground-floor rooms may have limited privacy due to visibility from outside. In-room amenities often include record players and provided bathrobes, adding to the unique charm. However, some guests note a lack of dresser space and the absence of coffee makers or mini-fridges in the rooms. Noise can be a concern due to thin walls, with some guests reporting audible conversations or piped-in music from adjacent areas.

Dining & Food Quality
While the hotel does not feature a full-service restaurant for all meals, guests have access to the adjacent Newes from America pub, which offers a charming atmosphere and good food. The Pelican Club and pool bar provide convenient options for drinks and light fare, with service available in the pool area. For morning coffee, guests receive a voucher for a nearby shop, though this typically covers only basic drip coffee, with other options incurring an additional charge. The absence of in-room coffee or tea-making facilities is a recurring point of feedback, requiring guests to seek out options elsewhere for their morning beverages.

Location & Accessibility
The hotel boasts an ideal central location in Edgartown, placing guests within easy walking distance of numerous shopping opportunities, diverse dining establishments, and the picturesque waterfront. Its proximity to the Chappy Ferry also makes it convenient for exploring other parts of the island. While the location is highly praised for its walkability and access to attractions, parking can be a significant challenge. On-site parking is very limited and operates on a first-come, first-served basis, with additional, small off-site spots available. Guests are advised that street parking is generally not permitted overnight in Edgartown, necessitating careful planning for vehicle accommodation.

Staff & Service
The staff generally receives praise for being friendly, helpful, and attentive, with many guests highlighting their efforts to make stays enjoyable, including offering room upgrades and providing local recommendations. However, there are instances of mixed feedback regarding service consistency. Some guests reported issues with check-in communication, including delays in room readiness and unfulfilled promises for early check-in notifications. Housekeeping service was occasionally noted as being late in the day or missed entirely, and some guests experienced a perceived lack of proactive assistance or an unwelcoming demeanor from certain front desk personnel. Despite these isolated concerns, the overall sentiment points to a dedicated team striving to provide a positive guest experience.

Additional Information
Guests should be aware that the hotel operates with a pet-friendly policy, though specific restrictions apply, such as pets not being permitted in the pool area. A notable feature is the hotel's signature scent, which is diffused throughout the property and, while generally well-received, can be overpowering for those sensitive to fragrances. The property, being a renovated historic building, does not have an elevator, which is an important consideration for guests with mobility issues or heavy luggage. Furthermore, daily housekeeping service is not automatically provided but must be requested by guests. Some guests have also noted a lack of dresser space in rooms, which can be inconvenient for longer stays.