How payments to us affect ranking

80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, 33036, USA
Select dates to see prices and availability
See prices
Amara Cay Resort
Amara Cay Resort
Amara Cay Resort
Amara Cay Resort
Amara Cay Resort

Good to know

  • On-site Italian and American dining

    Savor delicious meal choices at the ReelCatch restaurant, offering both Italian and American cuisine for breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

  • Oceanfront pool with tiki bar

    Relax by the shimmering oceanfront pool, featuring a lively poolside rum bar that serves lunch and dinner in a tropical setting.

  • Engaging 'Fish like a Local' program

    Participate in a unique, complimentary fishing lesson with Patrick on the dock, offering guests the chance to catch barracuda and needlefish.

  • Scenic ocean view rooms with balconies

    Many chic, island-themed rooms feature private balconies, providing breathtaking ocean views and the soothing sound of waves.

  • Award-winning interior design

    Experience a blend of relaxed atmosphere and luxurious style, recognized with the 2015 Sandi Design award for Design Excellence Hospitality.

  • Relaxing fire pits and live music

    Gather around the pretty fire pits in the courtyard area, often accompanied by live music, creating a warm and inviting evening ambiance.

  • Convenient local shuttle service

    Utilize the complimentary shuttle service for easy transportation to nearby restaurants, attractions, and other points of interest within 6 km.

  • Private beach with hammocks and loungers

    Unwind on the private beach area, complete with swaying palm trees, comfortable hammocks, and loungers for ultimate relaxation.

This summary was created by AI and might not be 100% accurate.

About Amara Cay Resort

This historical beach front hotel is located in Islamorada, and is within a three mile drive of the History of Diving Museum, and overlooks natural coral reefs, with beach front access. Visitors can enjoy cable TV in each of the rooms at Amara Cay Resort Islamorada , while other features include ironing facilities, a work desk and a safety deposit box. Amenities include an outdoor pool, spa and barbeque grill area, while an on-site business center features high speed internet. Parking is complimentary and bike rentals are available. Amara Cay Resort Islamorada Islamorada offers an outdoor and indoor dining experience, offering American and Italian cuisine, while breakfast is also served each morning. Anne’s Beach is just less than a ten minute drive from the hotel, while Hurricane Monument and Upper Matecumbe Key are a five minute drive away.

Rooms

  • Matacumbe Courtyard View King

    Matacumbe Courtyard View King

    • 1 1 King Bed and 1 Twin Sofa Bed
    • Sleeps 3
    • 378 sq ft
    • A/C
  • Alligator Reef Partial Ocean View 2 Queens

    Alligator Reef Partial Ocean View 2 Queens

    • 1 2 Queen Beds
    • Sleeps 4
    • 345 sq ft
    • A/C
  • Matacumbe Accessible King with Lanai

    Matacumbe Accessible King with Lanai

    • 1 1 King Bed
    • Sleeps 2
    • 378 sq ft
    • A/C
  • Matacumbe Courtyard View King Lanai

    Matacumbe Courtyard View King Lanai

    • 1 1 King Bed and 1 Twin Sofa Bed
    • Sleeps 3
    • 378 sq ft
    • A/C

Compare with similar stays

Selected stay

Amara Cay Resort (Islamorada, USA)

Select dates to see prices and availability
See prices

Similar stays

  • Fisher Inn Resort & Marina (Islamorada, USA)

    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • Treasure Harbor (Tavernier, USA)

    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • Hadley Resort and Marina (Islamorada, USA)

    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • Mangrove Marina Resort Llc (Tavernier, USA)

    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • Coconut Cove Resort and Marina (Islamorada, USA)

    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • Breezy Palms Resort (Islamorada, USA)

    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • Casa Morada (Islamorada, USA)

    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • La Jolla Resort (Islamorada, USA)

    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices

Price trend

Based on average prices on trivago from the last 30 days
Loading

Reviews

8.5
Excellent
based on 6,106 ratings from top 
sites

Review summary

Summarized by AI from 1,000+ reviews · Last updated: 29 May 2026

This resort is a vibrant, pet-friendly retreat ideal for families, couples, and sightseers seeking an engaging Florida Keys experience. The property boasts a prime location in Islamorada, offering easy walking access to local bars and restaurants. Its standout feature is the beautiful pool area and complimentary water sports equipment, including kayaks and paddleboards. Guests consistently praise the friendly and helpful staff, particularly the efficient front desk team and engaging shuttle drivers, and enjoy the quality food and diverse menu options, especially at the Tiki bar. For a unique and memorable activity, be sure to try the "Fish Like a Local" experience with Patrick.

Rated above average for Islamorada

Guest reviews

Excellent62%
Very good17%
Good10%
Fair5%
Poor6%

Top amenities

  • WiFi in lobby
  • Pool
  • Pets
  • A/C
  • Restaurant
  • Hotel bar
  • Gym

All amenities

Property amenities

  1. Café
  2. Entrance hall/lobby
  3. Express check-in/check-out
  4. Lift
  5. Gym
  6. Terrace
  7. Pet friendly
  8. Bar
  9. Pool bar
  10. Outdoor pool
  11. Conference rooms
  12. Non-smoking rooms

For children

  1. Cot
  2. Kid meals

Accessibility

  1. Wheelchair accessible
  2. Accessible travel path
  3. Accessible parking

Room amenities

  1. Openable windows
  2. Television
  3. Air conditioning
  4. Pay-TV
  5. Desk
  6. Small lounge
  7. Telephone
  8. Cable TV
  9. Fridge
  10. Coffee machine
  11. Flatscreen TV

Sports facilities

  1. Bike rental
  2. Golf course
  3. Fitness
  4. Surfing
  5. Diving
  6. Fishing
  7. Snorkelling
  8. Water sport facilities

Location

80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, 33036, USA

Distance from Amara Cay Resort

Islamorada:13.2 km

Florida Keys Marathon International Airport:44.5 km

Dadeland South:93.8 km

Theater of the Sea:7.2 km

History of Diving Museum:4.9 km

The Laura Quinn Wild Bird Sanctuary:21.2 km

Quarry Station:8.2 km

Dolphins Plus:29.8 km

African Queen:30.9 km

Islamorada Train Caboose:4.1 km

Island Adventures:1 km

Explore nearby attractions

Property info

80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, 33036, USA

Frequently Asked Questions about Amara Cay Resort

  • Is there a pool area at Amara Cay Resort?

    Yes, Amara Cay Resort offers 2 pool areas.

  • Are pets allowed at Amara Cay Resort?

    Yes, Amara Cay Resort has a pet policy that may vary based on the room type or availability. Please check with the hotel directly to learn about their pet policy.

  • Is parking available at Amara Cay Resort?

    Yes, Amara Cay Resort provides Accessible parking for guests.

  • What time is check-in and check-out at Amara Cay Resort?

    Check-in at Amara Cay Resort is available from: . Check-out time is by .

  • Where is Amara Cay Resort located?

    Amara Cay Resort is located at 80001 Overseas Hwy, 33036, Islamorada, USA.

The prices and availability we receive from booking sites change constantly. This means you may not always find the exact same offer you saw on trivago when you land on the booking site.

Among Top Rated Hotels in Islamorada

  • Casa Morada (Islamorada, USA)
    Hotel
    Casa Morada
    9.2Excellent (2,238 ratings)
    Islamorada, 9.7 km to City center
    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • The Islands of Islamorada (Islamorada, USA)
    Hotel
    The Islands of Islamorada
    9.4Excellent (320 ratings)
    Islamorada, 8.7 km to City center
    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • The Caribbean Resort (Islamorada, USA)
    Hotel
    The Caribbean Resort
    9.7Excellent (518 ratings)
    Islamorada, 10.0 km to City center
    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • The Moorings Village & Spa (Islamorada, USA)
    Hotel
    The Moorings Village & Spa
    9.7Excellent (215 ratings)
    Islamorada, 10.7 km to City center
    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • Bud N Marys Fishing Marina (Islamorada, USA)
    Hotel
    Bud N Marys Fishing Marina
    9.0Excellent (1,210 ratings)
    Islamorada, 13.6 km to City center
    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • Windley Cottage At Anglers Way (Islamorada, USA)
    Hotel
    Windley Cottage At Anglers Way
    10Excellent (487 ratings)
    Islamorada, 5.0 km to City center
    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • Caloosa Cove Resort (Islamorada, USA)
    Hotel
    Caloosa Cove Resort
    9.0Excellent (870 ratings)
    Islamorada, 23.2 km to City center
    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices
  • Topsider Resort by Capital Vacations (Islamorada, USA)
    Hotel
    Topsider Resort by Capital Vacations
    8.9Excellent (321 ratings)
    Islamorada, 20.4 km to City center
    Select dates to see prices and availability
    See prices

Other stays in Islamorada

Destinations near Amara Cay Resort

See all stays in Islamorada