The 1661 Inn

This charming island retreat is highly regarded for its stunning ocean views and the unique on-site animal farm, which contribute to a memorable stay. Guests consistently praise the spacious rooms, comfortable accommodations, and the exceptionally attentive staff. The delicious breakfast and convenient central location are also frequently highlighted as standout features. This hotel is an ideal choice for couples seeking a romantic getaway, families who appreciate the unique farm experience and ample room space, and sightseers or groups looking for a peaceful yet accessible base to explore the island. To enhance your visit, consider requesting a room with an ocean view for breathtaking sunrises and be sure to explore the charming animal farm.

Facilities & Amenities
Many accommodations offer luxurious features such as spa tubs or Jacuzzi tubs, cozy fireplaces, and practical amenities like refrigerators and coffeemakers. Some guests appreciate the thoughtful inclusion of humidifiers and ceiling fans. While most rooms are well-appointed, a few guests noted minor quirks with wall switches or the quality of some dressers. Free Wi-Fi is available throughout the property, though some guests experienced inconsistent internet connectivity. On-site parking is generally provided and often complimentary. The distinctive animal farm across the street is a significant and popular attraction, offering an engaging experience for guests of all ages. Additional conveniences include luggage storage and a helpful shuttle service to the ferry.

Cleanliness & Room Comfort
Guests largely commend the spacious and clean rooms, often describing them as well-kept and frequently newly renovated or beautifully decorated. Many rooms boast desirable features like ocean views or private patios. The beds are widely reported as very comfortable, contributing to a restful night's sleep, though a few guests found some mattresses to be too soft. Bathrooms are often highlighted as spacious and luxurious, equipped with features such as double showers and sinks, and some even include spa tubs. While the majority report excellent cleanliness, a few isolated reviews mention concerns about dirty bathrooms or areas not thoroughly cleaned, particularly in rooms with shared bathroom facilities. Noise levels are generally low, ensuring a peaceful environment.

Dining & Food Quality
The breakfast consistently receives high acclaim, often described as an outstanding buffet rather than a simple continental offering. Guests rave about the delicious and varied selections, which frequently include fresh produce from the hotel's own garden, homemade breads, muffins, pancakes, French toast, eggs, and even mimosas. The quality and freshness of the food, particularly the farm-to-table elements, significantly enhance the morning experience. Additionally, a complimentary afternoon wine and nibbles hour is a highly appreciated feature, providing a pleasant social opportunity with cheese and crackers while enjoying the scenic views.

Location & Accessibility
The hotel boasts an excellent central location, making it exceptionally convenient for guests. It is within easy walking distance of the ferry, the town center, various shops, and numerous restaurants. Many rooms and common areas offer stunning ocean views and picturesque vistas of the surrounding bluffs, providing a beautiful backdrop to the stay. The proximity to the hotel's own garden and animal farm is also a significant advantage, offering a unique on-site attraction. While most guests find the location perfect for exploring the island on foot, on-site parking is available for those who bring a vehicle, and a complimentary shuttle service to the ferry is often provided, adding to the overall convenience.

Staff & Service
The staff consistently receives glowing reviews for their exceptional friendliness, helpfulness, and attentiveness. Guests frequently highlight their welcoming demeanor and willingness to go above and beyond, from providing local tips and recommendations to assisting with luggage storage and offering early check-in or late check-out when possible. The check-in process is often described as smooth and efficient. Many guests feel treated like family, praising the personalized service and genuine care shown by the team. However, some guests have expressed significant dissatisfaction with the hotel's cancellation policy, citing a lack of compassion or flexibility in cases of unforeseen circumstances like ferry cancellations or medical emergencies.

Additional Information
A distinctive feature of the hotel is its on-site animal farm and garden, which not only provides fresh produce for breakfast but also offers an engaging experience for guests, particularly families. The hotel is well-known for its complimentary wine and nibbles hour in the afternoon, which serves as a popular social event. Guests appreciate the flexibility of luggage storage and the option to use facilities like showers even after checking out, especially before catching a ferry. The hotel also provides a convenient shuttle service to the ferry. While most experiences are positive, a recurring concern among some guests is the strict cancellation policy, which can be inflexible even in cases of weather-related travel disruptions or personal emergencies.